Defenders · Gameweek 1

Gabriel tops a defensive board Arsenal own

Four of the six best defensive picks this week face Coventry — the question is only which Arsenal asset to buy.

eBy the evmax model · 21 August 2026

Gabriel leads every defender and goalkeeper at 5.32 expected points: 1.78 of it from clean-sheet scenarios, a 27.7% chance of the defensive-contribution bonus, and the set-piece goal threat that gives him a 12.92 ceiling — the average of his best 15% of simulations. At £8.0m and 25.4% ownership he is the premium pick that actually justifies the word.

Gabriel5.32 → 12.92Calafiori5.12 → 13.88Tarkowski4.67 → 11.16Raya4.63 → 8.17Mosquera4.36 → 9.36Senesi4.35 → 10.55Virgil4.28 → 10.97N.Williams4.10 → 10.80Shaw3.98 → 7.99Mukiele3.71 → 10.55solid = xPts · faint = ceiling upside
Top 10 by xPts. Green = top pick · red = under 10% owned. Full list in the table below. Solid bar = xPts, faint bar = ceiling. Ceiling = the average of a player's best 15% of our 50,000 simulations — the score when his best realistic games happen, not a fantasy cap.

The cheaper Arsenal routes are almost as good. Calafiori projects 5.12 at £5.5m — 0.931 points per million, the best value of any player in the game this week — and Mosquera 4.36 at the same price. Raya is the top goalkeeper at 4.63, with 2.2 expected points from shutout scenarios alone. All four are priced off the same 56.8% clean-sheet probability against Coventry.

Outside the Emirates, the floor plays are Everton and Tottenham: Tarkowski and Senesi bank defensive-contribution points even when the clean sheet dies.

Tarkowski projects 4.67 with a 45.7% defensive-contribution probability — the classic two-route defender who scores from a shutout or from sheer defensive volume. Senesi (4.35) carries the highest defensive-contribution probability of any defender this week at 58.4%, which gives him a real floor even away at Brentford.

Bottom line: Gabriel at 5.32 is the week's best defensive buy; Calafiori at 0.931 points per million is its best bargain. Both outcomes hinge on the same Coventry fixture — diversify only if you already own two Arsenal assets.

The data

#PlayerxPtsCS ptsDefCon ptsBonusPrice
1Gabriel ARS5.321.780.550.978.0
2Calafiori ARS5.121.780.060.535.5
3Tarkowski EVEDifferential4.671.210.910.376.0
4Raya ARS4.632.200.000.396.0
5Mosquera ARS4.361.910.490.225.5
6Senesi TOT4.350.851.170.236.0
7Virgil LIV4.280.940.740.226.5
8N.Williams NFO4.101.120.260.395.0
9Shaw MUN3.981.780.150.074.5
10Mukiele SUNDifferential3.710.930.510.445.5
11Pickford EVEDifferential3.701.240.000.375.5
12Van Hecke TOTDifferential3.630.830.610.225.0
13Dalot MUNDifferential3.531.380.140.205.0
14Roefs SUNDifferential3.501.020.000.665.0
15Lammens MUN3.461.520.000.235.0
16Lacroix CRY3.380.820.960.156.0
17Keane EVEDifferential3.360.940.750.155.0
18Alderete SUNDifferential3.340.930.720.145.0
19Verbruggen BHA3.341.020.000.304.5
20Milenković NFODifferential3.301.150.520.045.5

Bottom line

Gabriel at 5.32 is the week's best defensive buy; Calafiori at 0.931 points per million is its best bargain. Both outcomes hinge on the same Coventry fixture — diversify only if you already own two Arsenal assets.

Get the next round the moment odds drop

50,000 simulations per matchday — captains, EV and match predictions in your inbox before lock.

Double opt-in. No spam, no tracking. Unsubscribe anytime.

How we get these numbers. Market odds (de-vigged) → Dixon-Coles scorelines → 50k Monte-Carlo simulations, scored on the official Fantasy Premier League points table. Every figure here is machine-readable at /api/fpl/gw1/defenders.json.